Even if you try to avoid all the Queen-for-a-Day style home improvement shows like I do, you still can’t escape their reach. From the missus' blog (where she professes her devotion to St. Ty of Pennington) to the Today Show (where they have transformed Rockefeller Plaza into “Humanity Plaza,” site of a makeshift modular home factory) to news that the First Lady will appear on Extreme Makeover: Home Edition (no doubt trying to reverse all the negative Gulf Coast vibes by flashing her bizarre, Joker-like smile at the downtrodden victims of Katrina).
Long before they sold their soul by giving BushCo yet another unwarranted chance to look good, I was creeped-out by Extreme Makeover. While it’s must-see TV for the missus, I can barely stand even being in the room while it’s on. The missus watches a few shows that I don’t like, but I can usually tune those shows out while with a good book. That's not the case with Extreme Makeover.
The thing is, when the missus asks me why I hate it so much, I have a hard time pinpointing my objections to the show. I’ve brought up the fact that it has a lottery mentality – where all your problems will go away if you just had a big new house. Since many of the families they help out live in economically depressed areas, I think the houses they build are inappropriate for their surroundings. I’m not saying that poor people can’t improve their homes but having a tricked-out mini-mansion show up (free!) in one week can’t be good for neighborhood relations, no matter how many smiling people show up for the unveiling. Also, since it’s often a minority family getting a hand up, I think the all-white cast unintentionally gives the impression that, once again, the white man has to save the day. And man, some of the dialog is so so contrived.
But those are all minor objections when you consider all the good these shows do, right? Well, I don’t think so, but like I said, I can’t figure out how to diagnose my disgust with these shows.
Luckily for me, Paul Brownfield of the LA Times, like Laura Bush after a category 5 political storm, has come to the rescue. His article, “Something Crass Lucks Behind The Do-Gooder Smile” hits the nail on the head (please forgive the pun). The article’s subtitle, “Charity on TV is never just about helping, it’s about being seen helping” covers why otherwise perky people like Katie Couric and Matt Lauer and the First Lady are so intent on getting their fingers dirty, but the article also goes into the whole strange culture of those charity shows.
I suggest you read the whole article, but there are some lines I really liked:
There are any number of complex emotional reactions the receiver of such largesse can have, but "Extreme Makeover" was clear: The camera probed his stoic soldier's gaze for gratitude or some moment of emotional catharsis, waiting for the payoff, until the whole thing became, inevitably, pornographic.
[…]
To be sure, the subjects are willing, even vying, to be on these shows, but there's still an unsettling transaction taking place: Make your private pain public, act it out for us, let us set it to music, and let us appear to have grown from our proximity to you. And in exchange we will give you a new house and a ride in a stretch limo and who knows what else — all the goodies that will inevitably, by their very goodi-ness, fix your problems. Oh, but we're only here for a week.
[…]
"Stop looking at your stuff for two seconds," Couric said at one point, trying to direct her back to center stage. She wanted little Jada to dance again.
[…]
The Bushes have visited Louisiana and Mississippi multiple times without creating a convincing narrative about their compassion. So Mrs. Bush is resorting to a surer thing, guesting on a series where the compassion, if it doesn't come across live, can be cobbled together in the editing room.
And, since I advertise myself as being self-righteous, I dig the article’s end:
"But when you give to the needy, do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing, so that your giving may be in secret," goes the Gospel of Matthew. Failing this, goes the gospel according to TV giving, put both hands together and give yourself a round of applause.
I have a feeling that this post isn’t going to put me in the missus’ good graces. Think Ty will come over and build a doghouse for me?
[Photo: Morry Gash / AP]